Understanding the Differences Between Pipe Relining and Pipe Replacement

When it comes to fixing damaged pipes, two popular options are pipe relining or pipe replacement. Both approaches aim to bring back the original function of your pipelines, but they have marked differences that are important to understand.
Key Takeaways
- Pipe relining is an economical and swift process for restoring damaged pipelines.
- Linings made of CIPP are used for pipe relining.
- Epoxy resin is used to line the inside areas of the pipe. This cures to creates a new inner lining for the pipeline.
- Relining pipelines is time-efficient, economical, and can last up to 50 years.
- The traditional method of replacing pipes is excavation of areas on the property in which pipes are located.
- Pipe replacement may be necessary for pipes that are badly damaged.
- A new pipeline installed through the replacement of a pipe has a long life span (75 or 100 years).
- The cost of replacing pipes is high and time-consuming.
- The decision between pipe relining and replacement is based on the extent of damage.
In this article, we’ll talk about pipe relining vs. pipe replacement. Find out which one suits your requirements better.
Is Pipe Relining a thing?
Pipe relining, also known as Cured-In-Place pipe (CIPP) Lining is a modern repair method which offers a low-cost and rapid solution for the repair of damaged pipelines.
Here’s how it works:
- A technician cleans the pipeline with high-pressure jetting or mechanical cleaning.
- Then, they apply epoxy resin made from fiberglass or polyester inside the pipeline.
- The liner cures and forms a new lining in the old pipeline that’s just as durable as a new one.
The advantages of Pipe Relining
- Time-efficient – It usually takes only 2 to three hours for the entire process, as opposed to digging for several days with traditional methods of replacing pipes.
- Cost-effective Since no excavation or removal is necessary for pipe relining, it can save almost 50% of the cost you’d spend on traditional repairs.
- Durability – The new lining created through pipe relining can last for up to 50 years!
Pros and Cons of Pipe Relining
- Not recommended for extremely damaged pipes - If there are significant damages such as cracks, collapses, or misaligned joints within your sewer line then pipe relining could not be possible.
What is Pipe Replacement?
Pipe replacement involves digging up portions of the yard/sidewalk/driveway where underground pipes are located. The sections could include broken pipes, or very damaged ones due to negligence or aging.
The following steps are typical of traditional pipe replacements:
- An excavation crew digs access to the degraded underground pipe.
- The pipeline that was previously in use is detachment and dredged out, producing a lot debris that needs to be disposed of.
- Then, they construct the new pipeline on top of the previous one.
Pros of Pipe Replacement
- Perfect for severely damaged pipes Ideal for severely damaged pipes – If you must replace pipes that have severe corrosion or damage, pipe replacement is the best solution.
- Long lifespan – The new pipeline installed through pipe replacement is long-lasting (75 up to 100 years) making it an ideal option for homeowners looking for the best solution for their home.
Pros of Pipe Replacement
- The work of excavation required for the replacement of pipes is costly and time-consuming.
- It is time-consuming. Pipe replacements may take weeks depending on the size of the work and depth of excavations required.
Which one should you choose?
The choice between the option of relining or replacing your pipes mostly is contingent on the level of damage caused. If your pipes suffer from minor damage, such as cracks or leaks of a minor size, replacing them is likely to be the best option, as it is less costly as well as quicker than traditional replacements.
If there are major injuries, like breaks or collapses, then you should consider conventional pipe replacement, though it may be more expensive and takes longer.
Pipe Relining | Pipe Replacement | |
---|---|---|
Procedure | CIPP lining using epoxy resin | Excavating and replacing the old pipeline |
Pros | Time-efficient- 2 to 3 hours to complete | Suitable for severely damaged pipes |
Cost-effective – Almost half of traditional costs. | New pipeline lasts for 75 to 100 years | |
Durable – Lasts up to 50 years | ||
Cons | Not suitable for severely damaged pipes | Costly |
Time-consuming | ||
When to choose | Minor damages like cracks or minor leaks | Severe damages like collapses or breaks |
Common Questions and Answers
What is the process of relining pipes?
Relining of pipes is a procedure that creates a brand new pipe inside the existing damaged pipe. This is done by inserting a flexible liner in the existing pipe, and then placing it into place. After curing, the new pipe is free of joints or seams, which enhances its structural integrity.
How does traditional pipe replacement differ from pipe relining?
Traditional pipe replacement involves digging and physically removing old pipes, after which they are replaced with new ones. The alternative, pipe relining doesn’t require excavation; instead it’s done by using technology that permits repair of pipelines without digging vast areas of land.
Which option is less expensive: the pipe relining method or traditional pipe replacement?
Relining pipes typically cost less than traditional methods of pipeline repair as there is no cost related to excavation or other procedures necessary for removing and replacing old pipes.
Can all types of pipes be lined?
Not all types of pipes can be successfully relined. Your plumber should examine your particular situation to determine whether it’s possible to line the particular kind of pipes. But, the majority of modern pipes can be fixed with this technique.
How long does the pipe relining process take?
The exact duration of the procedure is contingent upon various elements like the location, the environment and the kind of damage. However the average pipe Relining job typically takes around 2 days based on the amount of meters need to be lined..
In the end, if you want to avoid invasive excavation work and save your money while restoring damaged pipelines’ function to its maximum, consider opting for our Blocked Drains Plumbers Sydney ‘s swift and efficient pipeline relining services. Contact us!
Additional Information
- How to Tell You Need Drain Clearing Services for Your Business
- The Ultimate Guide to Pipe Relining: How to Select the Perfect Material
- Pipe Relining: The Intelligent Technique to Fix Your Sewer
- Why Consider Pipe Relining for Your Residential or Commercial Property
- From Start to End: Everything to Expect During Pipe Relining
- Preserve Your Piping by Prompt Relining: Ways to Recognize When
- Why Your Business Needs Periodic Drain Inspection and Cleaning
- Top 5 Benefits of CCTV Drain Inspection for Your Plumbing System
- The Positive Effect of Pipe Relining on the Environment
- The Ultimate Guide to Prevent Drain Blockages